I chose AmeriFreight because of the commendable BBB and customer reviews.  
After speaking to a few companies, I found AmeriFreight to be the most expensive of all choices.  I wondered about this - but after research, felt the upfront expenses (versus other companies have lower costs with hidden fees and poor reviews) was worth it.
I spoke with Jonathan the first time I called.  He was knowledgeable.  When I called to confirm I was directed to Luke.  I explained I had no problem paying the expedited fees (1 day or 2 day - either was fine as long as the car could get shipped right away).  He kept speaking about the usual preferred shipping....I felt like I was trying to SELL HIM my business.  It was a bit frustrating.  Come to find out, Luke does not have as much experience with the expedited orders - maybe that is why he didn't talk about it.
Another thing that was annoying was the customer service.  I think Luke was trying to be friendly but came across as disrespectful (note to seller:  your funny jokes may not be funny to others - don't mock people's states).  However, after he realized I found his attitude less than funny, Luke worked on a more professional level.
I had my car picked up today at 5 p.m. - and that was the agreement.  Luke and I spoke today and he was much more professional - I appreciated that.  Overall, I give AmeriFreight an adequate rating.  I felt I had to do a lot of the touching base (versus them being more pro-active at calling / contacting me) - but would use them again in the future.
                    
                 
                
             
            
            
            
            
            
            
                
            
         
                
                
                    
                    Company Response
                    AmeriFreight from 
AmeriFreight Car Shipping Submitted this response.
                    
Response Date: 5/5/2010 7:53:00 PM
                    
                        This person's order was handled by our Shipping Agent, Luke- direct line 678-369-2364.